I just wanted to voice my opinion on the matter. First of all, I think criminalizing modifications to a console is a terrible idea. There are two purposes for modding a console, playing homebrew(home made applications, which is perfectly LEGAL) and playing pirated games. While I acknowledge that perhaps the majority of people who mod, do it to play illegal copies, I think its despicable that people are imprisoned SOLELY for modding, whether or not they played illegal copies. We, as consumers, OWN the console after we buy it and therefore have the right to do whatever we want with any products we BOUGHT. Playing homebrew involves no copyright infringement. Often, console features which publishers don't bother to release, are unlocked by hackers, like in the case of the homebrew DVD player on the
The DMCA(Digital Millennium Copyright Act) criminalizes any attempts at circumventing any measures at controlling access to copyrighted material. But, this is in itself an unfair act. It doesn't criminalize copyright infringement (because that was already illegal), it criminalizes any method which gives the user the ability to illegally use copyrighted materials. This sounds okay until you realize that modding consoles isn't so much making a console piracy enabled as it is freeing up the device to do any number of things which the console maker deemed was "undesirable". The DMCA, most recently, has been used by Apple to justify their argument in criminalizing the unlocking of their Iphones. They have even stated that an unlocked
The second case which I stated above brings to mind my feelings about how the video game industry, and publishers especially, need to reconsider their profit-driven business models. It seems like every month, the MSRP for video games goes up by another $10. I know that publishers getting $0 for their work is not a solution, but neither is prosecuting everyone who downloads an illegal copy of their games. Maybe the studio should be looking at what would attract a user to buy the game rather than download it. About half a year ago, Steam did some research by adjusting their prices and found that when they cut
UPDATE: So Activision CEO Bobby Kotick further shows that many video game companies haven't grasped the concept of lowering prices to reach a wider audience. He makes a comment about his desire to increase prices on games despite the fact that the economy is in shambles and unemployment is rampant.
Comments
No responses to “Video Game Piracy and the DMCA”
Post a Comment